Welcome
Creating Memories, One Cookie at a Time
Get ready for beautiful and delicious treats for your next event
Custom treats for every celebration
From beautifully decorated sugar cookies and delicious cupcakes to stunning custom birthday cakes, we create sweet treats that are as memorable as they are tasty. Whether you already have a theme in mind or need help bringing one to life, we’ll work with you to design desserts that perfectly match your vision — or help you dream up something completely unique. Let us make your next celebration extra special!
What we do: A Sneak Peek
Order for a baby shower themed Perfect in Pink!
Cookie decorating kits for a fun AND delicious treat
Custom cake for a four year old birthday party themed Mermaids!
Menu / Price List
Decorated Sugar Cookies
Prices below are by the dozen with a minimum purchase of a dozen. Prices are also considered a "base price" and may vary depending on designs and decorative needs.
Two Toned Piped
$36
Base of cookie is a solid color with a piped decoration in a different color.
Themed or Multiple Color
$42
Cookie design follows a specific theme requiring multiple layers of depth and color.
Hand Painted
$30
Cookie will have a solid base color with hand painted, one dimensional designs.
Individual Bags
$3
Each cookie will be added in a bag with a twist tie and decorative ribbon
Cupcakes
Prices below are by the dozen with a minimum purchase of a dozen. Prices are also considered a "base price" and may vary depending on designs and decorative needs.
Frosted and Topper Ready
$24
One dozen of the same flavor cake decorated with whatever color and flavor frosting ready to be completed with cupcake toppers.
Sprinkles are available
Frosting Decorated
$30
One dozen of the same flavor cake decorated to a theme or desired style with whatever color and flavor frosting.
Sprinkles are available
Two Layer Fondant Decorated
$75
One dozen of the same flavor cake decorated to a theme or desired style with whatever color and flavor frosting and completed with three dimensional decorations.
Add ons
Additional cupcakes $2
Fondant applications $2 Each
Decorated Cakes
Prices below are considered a "base price" and may vary depending on designs and decorative needs.
Two Layer Cake Topper Ready
$45
Two layers of the same flavored cake decorated in whatever color and flavor frosting ready to be completed with a cake topper.
Sprinkles are available.
Two Layer Frosting Decorated
$60
Two layers of the same flavored cake decorated for a theme or style in the flavor of frosting of choice.
Two Layer Fondant Decorated
$75
Two layers of the same flavored cake decorated for a theme or style in the flavor of frosting of choice with a layer of decorative fondant on top.
Add ons
Additional tiers of cake $15
Fondant applications $5 Each
Quick Cookies
Ask about our cookie set of the month for a quick cookie treat. We also offer cookie kits for decorating and enjoying.
Cookie Set of the month
$15
A set of 3 cookies right on theme for you to gift or enjoy. The design and flavor is pre chosen with the ability to choose packaging.
Examples:
- Valentines
- Back to School
- Halloween
- Christmas
Individual Cookie Kit
$20
Be a cookie decorator with your own kit. Set includes 6 cookies, 3 icing colors, 3 small bags of sprinkles.
Choice of cookie designs.
Additional cookies $1 each
Party Cookie Kit
36
Be a cookie decorator with your own kit. Set includes 15 cookies, 6 icing bags, 6 small bags of sprinkles.
Choice of cookie designs.
Additional cookies $1 each
Prices include baked goods, packaging, hand delivery and guarantee upon delivery. Guarantee - the baked good ordered is in tact and correctly decorated. Any disturbed treat after the package has been opened is not the responsibility of The Cookie Tester. Any issues before the box is opened will be reimbursed or replaced at customers desire.
Follow The Cookie Tester on Instagram
Put in your order request here
Note: these are order requests - Please await confirmation
Get Ready for The Cookie Tester!
Placing an Order
- To place an order request please message through Instagram or directly on our website.
- Once confirmed by The Cookie Tester, and deposit received, you can lock in your order.
- Place order requests with a minimum of two weeks advanced notice to guarantee date and design.
- Rush orders are available at the bakers discretion.
- Order deliveries are scheduled for Thursday through Sunday.
Payment
- To lock in your order, a $20 deposit is required.
- Payments can be done through ATH Movil, Venmo or PayPal. (information on Invoice)
Delivery
- All orders have free delivery in the San Juan Metro area.
- Uber carrier is also available with the customer covering the cost.)
Contact Us
Better yet, let's chat. Anything you need, we are here!
We love our customers, so feel free to write us whenever you need and we will be sure to get back to you as soon as you can say COOKIE.
The Cookie Tester
This website uses cookies.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.